The Ins and Outs of Non-Profit Board Insurance

Discover the essentials of non-profit board insurance, from D&O coverage to choosing the right policy, in our comprehensive guide for nonprofits.


Understanding Board Insurance, Importance for Non-Profits

When it comes to steering a nonprofit, the board of directors plays a pivotal role, navigating through both calm and stormy waters. But what happens when legal disputes or allegations threaten to capsize the journey? This is where Non-Profit Board Insurance, also known as Directors & Officers (D&O) liability insurance, becomes an indispensable lifesaver.

Simply put, Non-Profit Board Insurance is designed to protect the personal assets of board members and officers, covering legal fees, settlements, and potential financial losses from lawsuits. Why is this important? Because even with the best intentions, allegations of mismanagement, breaches of fiduciary duty, or regulatory noncompliance can result in costly legal battles that jeopardize both individual members and the organization’s mission.

In a nutshell, having the right insurance ensures that your nonprofit can continue to operate and serve the community, even amidst legal challenges. It attracts and retains qualified leaders by offering them protection against personal financial loss. In doing so, it safeguards your organization’s future, leadership, and mission.

Infographic depicting the key components and benefits of Non-Profit Board Insurance: 1. Legal fee coverage, 2. Protection of personal assets, 3. Safeguarding the nonprofit's mission, 4. Attracting and retaining board members. - non profit board insurance infographic step-infographic-4-steps

What is Non-Profit Board Insurance?

Non-Profit Board Insurance, often referred to as Directors & Officers (D&O) Insurance, is a type of policy designed to protect the personal assets of board members and officers in the event of a legal claim against them for actions taken in their official capacity. This insurance plays a crucial role in the governance and sustainability of non-profit organizations by providing Liability Protection and Personal Asset Safety.

D&O Insurance

At its core, D&O Insurance acts as a safety net for the decision-makers of non-profit organizations. It covers the costs associated with the defense, settlements, or judgments arising from lawsuits alleging wrongful acts in managing the organization. These wrongful acts could include breach of duty, misuse of the organization’s funds, fraudulent acts, or failure to comply with regulations among others.

Liability Protection

An essential function of non-profit board insurance is to offer liability protection. It means if a lawsuit is filed against a director or an officer, the insurance policy can cover legal fees, settlements, and other expenses related to the lawsuit. This protection is vital as it prevents board members from having to pay out of pocket, ensuring that their personal finances are not at risk due to their voluntary or professional involvement with the non-profit.

Personal Asset Safety

One of the most compelling reasons for non-profit organizations to invest in D&O Insurance is the protection of personal assets. Without this insurance, board members’ personal assets, such as their homes, cars, and savings, could be targeted to satisfy legal claims. By providing a layer of security, D&O Insurance allows individuals to serve on boards without fear of personal financial ruin.

Non-Profit Board Insurance is not just a policy; it’s a commitment to safeguarding the individuals who steer the mission and vision of non-profits. It ensures that the personal risk associated with serving as a board member or officer is minimized, allowing these key leaders to focus on advancing the organization’s objectives with confidence.

For further information on the specifics of Non-Profit Board Insurance and how it can benefit your organization, consider reaching out to experts like Griffith & Harris, who specialize in this essential coverage.

Transitioning smoothly into our next section, understanding the key benefits of D&O Insurance for non-profits is equally crucial. These benefits go beyond legal fee coverage and personal asset protection, extending into areas such as fiduciary malfeasance and wrongful termination claims. Let’s explore these benefits in detail.

Key Benefits of D&O Insurance for Non-Profits

When it comes to protecting your non-profit and the people who lead it, Directors & Officers (D&O) Insurance is not just an option; it’s a necessity. Here’s why:

Defense Costs

Legal battles can drain your non-profit’s resources. D&O Insurance takes care of the defense costs, ensuring that your organization can continue its mission without financial strain. Whether the claims are founded or not, you’re covered.

Settlements and Judgments

If a lawsuit against your non-profit reaches a settlement or results in a judgment, the financial implications can be significant. D&O Insurance covers these costs, safeguarding your non-profit’s financial health and future.

Fiduciary Malfeasance

Mistakes in managing the organization’s finances? D&O Insurance provides a safety net. It covers claims of mismanagement, ensuring that unintentional errors don’t lead to personal liabilities for directors and officers.

Wrongful Termination Claims

Employees may sue for wrongful termination. D&O Insurance includes Employment Practices Liability (EPLI), covering claims from employees alleging wrongful acts in the employment process, including discrimination, harassment, and wrongful termination.

Understanding these benefits underscores the importance of D&O Insurance for non-profits. It’s not just about legal fees; it’s about protecting your mission, your people, and your future. With the right coverage, your organization can navigate challenges confidently, knowing that it has a robust safety net in place.

One real concern shared by a new board member on an online forum highlights the importance of D&O Insurance. They questioned their participation in a non-profit trade association without such insurance, pointing out the legitimacy of their concern for personal liability protection . This scenario illustrates the critical role of D&O Insurance in attracting and retaining qualified board members who are essential for the growth and success of a non-profit organization.

It’s clear that choosing the right non-profit board insurance involves understanding the specific needs of your organization and the potential risks it faces. With these key benefits in mind, let’s delve into how to select the ideal D&O Insurance for your non-profit.

Who Needs Non-Profit Board Insurance?

In non-profit organizations, every decision made and action taken can be under scrutiny. It’s a realm where passion meets duty, and where the consequences of missteps can be severe—not just for the organization, but for the individuals who guide it. This is where non-profit board insurance, particularly Directors and Officers (D&O) insurance, becomes not just beneficial, but essential.

Directors and Officers
These are the individuals who make the big decisions. They set strategies, oversee operations, and ensure the organization’s mission is being pursued effectively. Their roles involve a high level of responsibility and, consequently, a high level of risk. Without D&O insurance, their personal assets could be at stake in the event of legal action against the organization.

Managers, those who run the day-to-day operations, also find themselves in need of protection. They may make employment decisions, handle funds, and engage with clients or beneficiaries—all actions that carry potential liabilities. While not always covered under D&O insurance, their roles underscore the need for comprehensive non-profit board insurance that includes Employment Practices Liability (EPLI).

Non-Profit Organizations
As entities, non-profit organizations face risks that can threaten their existence. From financial mismanagement claims to breaches of fiduciary duty, the organization itself needs protection to survive these challenges. Non-profit board insurance safeguards the organization, ensuring it can continue its mission even when faced with legal hurdles.

Board Members
Every board member, regardless of their experience level or the size of their role, faces potential liability. Whether it’s a decision that leads to financial loss or an unintentional legal misstep, the personal consequences can be dire. Non-profit board insurance provides a safety net, ensuring that board members can focus on their roles without the looming fear of personal financial ruin.

Non-profit board insurance is not a luxury—it’s a necessity for anyone involved in the leadership and management of a non-profit organization. It’s about protecting not just the organization and its mission, but the individuals who pour their time, energy, and passion into making a difference. This coverage ensures that a momentary lapse or an unforeseen legal challenge doesn’t derail the organization or devastate the lives of those who lead it.

As we continue to explore the intricacies of non-profit board insurance, remember: the right coverage can mean the difference between flourishing in your mission and facing insurmountable obstacles. For those steering the ship of a non-profit, it’s not just about managing risk—it’s about ensuring the longevity and success of your cause.

For a real-life concern regarding the importance of D&O insurance from a new board member’s perspective, see this discussion on Reddit.

As we’ve seen, non-profit board insurance is a critical component in safeguarding the individuals and organizations committed to making a difference. But how do you choose the right policy? In the next section, we’ll delve into selecting the ideal D&O Insurance for your non-profit, covering everything from coverage features to policy limits.

Common Misconceptions About Non-Profit Board Insurance

When it comes to non-profit board insurance, there are a few myths that can cloud our understanding and decision-making process. Let’s clear the air on some common misconceptions regarding personal liability, coverage scope, and cost concerns.

Personal Liability: “Board Members Are Personally Protected Without Insurance”

A common mistake is thinking board members are automatically protected from personal liability. The truth is, while serving a non-profit, decisions you make can lead to legal actions against you personally. Non-profit board insurance, specifically Directors & Officers (D&O) liability insurance, is designed to protect your personal assets from these risks.

Coverage Scope: “All Risks Are Covered”

D&O insurance has its limitations. While it covers a wide range of wrongful acts, including breach of fiduciary duty and employment practices violations, it does not cover criminal acts or fraud. Each policy has its own set of exclusions, and it’s crucial to be aware of these when selecting your insurance. For example, while some policies might offer unique coverages like protection against HIPAA violations or third-party discrimination claims, not all do. Being clear on what your policy covers is essential to ensuring you’re adequately protected.

Cost Concerns: “D&O Insurance Is Too Expensive for Small Non-Profits”

Another major misconception is the cost-prohibitive nature of D&O insurance for smaller non-profits. While it’s true that costs can vary, the median cost of D&O coverage for nonprofits is around $855 annually for $1 million in coverage. Considering the potential financial implications of legal action against your board, this is a relatively small price to pay for peace of mind and financial security. Moreover, going without coverage can result in much higher expenses in case of a lawsuit, far outweighing the cost of premiums.

When considering non-profit board insurance, it’s vital to dispel these misconceptions. Understanding the true nature of personal liability, what your coverage actually includes, and the real costs associated with insurance can help you make informed decisions to protect both yourself and your organization.

It’s important to know how to select the right D&O policy for your non-profit. Let’s explore the key considerations in choosing the most suitable coverage to meet your organization’s needs, from policy features to employment practices liability.

How to Choose the Right Non-Profit Board Insurance

Choosing the right non-profit board insurance can feel like navigating a maze. Here’s how to simplify the process and ensure you’re adequately protected.

Coverage Features

Start by understanding exactly what you’re getting. Not all D&O insurance policies are created equal. Look for policies that cover a broad range of “wrongful acts,” including breach of fiduciary duty, employment practices liability, and any legal defense costs.

Key Tip: Make sure your policy explicitly covers both current and past directors and officers. This is crucial because claims can arise after a board member has left the organization.

Policy Limits

Decide how much coverage you need. This is often determined by your non-profit’s size, the scope of its operations, and the level of risk involved in its activities. A larger non-profit or one that engages in higher-risk activities may need a policy with a higher limit.

Remember: It’s not just about the maximum payout, but also about understanding what’s realistically sufficient for your organization.

Deductible Options

Higher deductibles can lower your premium costs but mean more out-of-pocket expenses when a claim is made. Choose a deductible that balances affordability with your non-profit’s financial stability.

Consideration: Assess your non-profit’s financial health. Can it afford a higher deductible if that means significantly lower premiums?

Employment Practices Liability (EPLI)

EPLI is a critical component of D&O insurance for non-profits. It protects against claims made by employees, such as wrongful termination, discrimination, and harassment.

Fact: In today’s workplace, employment practices claims are among the most common litigation threats to non-profits. Ensure your policy includes robust EPLI coverage.

Fiduciary Liability

If your non-profit manages employee benefit plans, fiduciary liability coverage is essential. It protects against claims of mismanagement of these plans.

Why It Matters: Breaches in fiduciary duty can result in significant financial losses and legal challenges. Ensure your D&O policy includes or offers an option to add fiduciary liability coverage.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right non-profit board insurance isn’t just about ticking a box; it’s about safeguarding your organization’s future and the personal assets of its directors and officers. By focusing on coverage features, policy limits, deductible options, EPLI, and fiduciary liability, you can select a policy that provides comprehensive protection tailored to your non-profit’s unique risks and needs.

For a deeper dive into understanding the ins and outs of non-profit board insurance, consider exploring more about the topic. A great starting point is this detailed discussion on the types of insurance a non-profit should consider to protect itself and its board members.

Navigating the complexities of D&O insurance doesn’t have to be daunting. With the right information and a clear understanding of your non-profit’s needs, you can make informed decisions to protect both yourself and your organization as we move into the next section.

Frequently Asked Questions about Non-Profit Board Insurance

When it comes to non-profit board insurance, there are a few questions that pop up more often than others. Let’s dive into these questions to help you understand the ins and outs a bit better.

Do Nonprofit Board Members Need Insurance?

Absolutely. Non-profit board members make decisions that can have significant legal and financial implications. Even though they often work with the best intentions, things can go wrong. For example, a decision that negatively impacts a third party could lead to a lawsuit. Having D&O insurance provides a safety net, ensuring that board members are not left to handle legal fees and settlements out of their own pockets.

What is Covered Under D&O Insurance for Nonprofits?

D&O insurance for nonprofits covers a range of potential issues, including:

  • Legal defense costs: This can include lawyers’ fees, court costs, and any expenses related to defending against a claim.
  • Settlements and judgments: If the nonprofit and its board members are found liable, the policy can cover the costs of settlements or judgments awarded.
  • Claims of fiduciary malfeasance: If a board member is accused of failing in their duty to manage the nonprofit’s assets responsibly, D&O insurance can provide protection.
  • Wrongful termination claims: This covers legal defense and settlements if a former employee sues the nonprofit for wrongful termination.

D&O insurance does not cover fraudulent, criminal acts, or those committed with malicious intent.

How Much Does Non-Profit Board Insurance Cost?

The cost of non-profit board insurance can vary widely based on several factors, including the size of the organization, the scope of its operations, and the level of coverage chosen. On average, small- to mid-sized nonprofits might expect to pay around $855 annually for $1 million in coverage. However, this is just a median figure; your organization’s specific circumstances could lead to higher or lower premiums.

The cost of not having D&O insurance could be much higher if a lawsuit occurs. Legal defense fees alone can quickly surpass the annual premium of a D&O policy.

Considering D&O insurance is an investment in your nonprofit’s future stability and the personal financial security of its board members. Ensuring your organization and its leaders are protected against unforeseen legal challenges is crucial.

For more detailed information and personalized advice, it’s always best to consult with an insurance expert who understands the unique needs of nonprofits.
non profit board insurance - non profit board insurance

Next, we’ll move into the conclusion, where we’ll wrap up our discussion on non-profit board insurance and highlight how Griffith & Harris Insurance Services can assist your organization in navigating these waters.


In wrapping up our guide on non-profit board insurance, it’s crucial to recognize that the landscape of liability and protection for non-profit organizations is both complex and nuanced. Directors and Officers (D&O) Liability Insurance emerges not just as a safety net but as a foundational element in safeguarding the personal assets of those who manage and direct these organizations. It’s a testament to the commitment of board members, offering them peace of mind as they steer their non-profits towards their missions.

At this juncture, the importance of partnering with a knowledgeable and experienced insurance provider cannot be overstated. This is where Griffith & Harris Insurance Services steps in. With our deep understanding of the unique challenges and liabilities faced by non-profits, we are ideally positioned to offer tailored insurance solutions that meet the specific needs of your organization.

Our approach goes beyond merely providing insurance. We aim to be a partner in your mission, ensuring that your board members are not just protected but are also empowered to make bold decisions for the betterment of your cause. From addressing common misconceptions about non-profit board insurance to navigating the intricacies of coverage features, policy limits, and deductible options, our team is here to guide you every step of the way.

In summary, non-profit board insurance is an indispensable tool in the governance and management of non-profit organizations. It ensures that the individuals who pour their heart and soul into these causes can do so without the looming threat of personal liability. Griffith & Harris Insurance Services is committed to providing you with the protection and peace of mind needed to focus on what matters most – your mission.

As we close our guide, the journey towards effective protection for your non-profit doesn’t have to be navigated alone. Let Griffith & Harris Insurance Services be your ally in securing a brighter, safer future for your organization.

Contact us today, and let’s take the first step towards safeguarding your non-profit’s tomorrow.

For more information Call:


Reach Out Now

"*" indicates required fields


Recent Blog Posts:


We strive to deliver prompt, courteous and responsive service every time. This is a basic principle in every situation and a cause for success. Contact us today for a free consultation. 


Sign up to our newsletter

"*" indicates required fields

Practice Areas